The Orioles’ signing of Dylan Carlson continues their trend of low-key offseason moves, adding a player who offers versatility but little fanfare. Carlson’s one-year deal for $975,000 gives Baltimore a switch-hitting outfielder who can play all three outfield positions, but his recent offensive struggles raise questions about his role and impact.
Once a highly touted prospect and NL Rookie of the Year finalist in 2021, Carlson’s production has declined steadily since his impressive debut. His .266/.343/.437 rookie slash line feels like a distant memory after posting a dismal .515 OPS with the Cardinals and .615 OPS with the Rays in 2024. These numbers suggest he’s far from reclaiming his early-career form.
Carlson’s splits against left-handed pitching could provide some utility as a pinch hitter or occasional starter against southpaws, but his performance might not justify consistent playing time. With three minor league options remaining, he could easily begin the season at Triple-A Norfolk, adding organizational depth rather than immediate value to the MLB roster. Comparisons to other reclamation projects like Daz Cameron highlight the Orioles’ ongoing focus on bargain-bin additions rather than splashy acquisitions.
To make room for Carlson on the 40-man roster, the Orioles designated infielder Jacob Amaya for assignment. Amaya, a largely unremarkable player in terms of MLB experience, appears to be a casualty of the team’s cautious roster-building approach.
For Orioles fans hoping for a more aggressive push after three consecutive winning seasons, this signing likely feels underwhelming. However, Carlson’s versatility and former prospect pedigree might make him a worthwhile gamble—if he can somehow recapture his early promise. Otherwise, he risks becoming another fleeting name in Baltimore’s quest to build a sustainable contender.
Leave a Reply