The Philadelphia Phillies have a well-rounded roster with both a strong pitching staff and a formidable lineup, leaving little room for major upgrades. However, there is one potential trade that could benefit the team both immediately and in the long run. In this scenario, the Phillies would trade their All-Star third baseman, Alec Bohm, to the St. Louis Cardinals in exchange for ten-time Gold Glove winner Nolan Arenado.
During the offseason, the Phillies explored trading Bohm but were unable to finalize a deal. This proposal provides them with a trade partner, leading to a major shakeup for both teams. The Cardinals would gain a younger, more affordable, and flexible player in Bohm, who remains under team control through 2026 before hitting free agency. Meanwhile, the Phillies, who benched Bohm during the 2024 NLDS against the Mets, might be open to a change at third base.
Arenado, a key name on the trade market, has three years remaining on his hefty contract, earning $21 million in 2025, followed by $16 million in 2026 and $15 million in 2027. Although he comes at a higher cost, he presents a greater upside for the Phillies. Additionally, with Aidan Miller potentially emerging as a future third baseman, moving Bohm could make strategic sense.
Despite Arenado’s struggles in 2024 and a rough Spring Training, a fresh start in Philadelphia might help him regain his form. Meanwhile, Bohm excelled in Spring Training, adding to the Cardinals’ appeal. If the Phillies make this move, it could be the key to propelling them back to the World Series.
